Wednesday, January 15, 2020

Professional costs


I love my job. I really do. I get to spend my career following my passion.  But like most things, it comes at a cost. So many professionals have died lately, and more are opening up about their battles with depression, I feel the need to pull back the rug a little and try to show that cost.

Most recently, Teresa Butta died on New Year’s Eve.  We were acquaintances--we moved in the same circles, rode with the same instructor, attended the same clinics and shows, and were about the same age.  We had big dreams.  

I can’t look at her death, and look at my health breakdown two years ago, followed by necessary business and life changes, and not think “there, but for the grace of god, go I.”

The horse business is tough - everyone says that. But those words don’t even touch the surface.

Working in any highly competitive performance-based industry, be it athletics, the arts, academia, some corporate settings, is tough, because you are always, always trying to be the best. Not your best, but THE best, in order to survive. Any performance-based industry has a “what have you done lately?” mentality. Recent show results are much more important than awards won 20 years ago. 

Dressage riders are hard-wired with a type-A, perfectionistic, it’s-never-good-enough mindset--professionals even more so.    Even when we win, our score sheets detail areas to improve. The impossible standard of a “10” leaves every single one of us with a healthy dose of imposter syndrome. 

In the horse industry, we get the double-whammy of working in the service industry.  Unless a trainer is quite fortunate with sponsors or family money, the lights are paid by other people’s horses, other people’s dreams, other people’s goals.  Supporting client’s dreams and goals, often while we watch ours be sidelined by time, injury, or finances, is emotionally quite heavy. 

So heavy in fact that in the CBS article dated June 2016, entitled “These Jobs have the Highest Suicide Rate,”  agriculture/farming workers (which all of us who manage a farm are part of) ranked #1, and service industry workers ranked #19.

The finances in this job add to the pressure--this industry runs on insanely small profit margins.  The overhead is crazy high. Board generally breaks even, and owning a competition horse isn’t cheap.  Even when the long-term goal is sales, the carrying costs, promotion costs, and training time aren’t paid until the horse sells.   Most horse trainers are one colic surgery, one expensive truck repair, one lost training client away from sleepless nights and robbing Peter to pay Paul.  When clients drive up in late-model expensive cars and complain about the cost of a lesson, not getting bitter is an active choice, one that’s really hard to make at the end of a cold, wet, physically-tiring 12-hour day.  

We all walked into this career knowing we weren’t going to get rich, but we expected it to be fun.  Being close to burnout all the time isn’t fun, not even a little. 

Most often we are head trainers, or work alone, and the saying “it’s lonely at the top” is real.  When trainers do get the rare luxury of gathering with other pros, our competitive, perfectionistic nature makes it hard to let our guard down.  Talking about how many horses are in your program, how long your days are, how many days you’ve worked without a day off is a status symbol. Rarely do we ask each other if we are having fun, or what we do outside of the barn. We are so used to keeping up the veneer of success for our clients, that we can’t even let it down in front of our peers.  It’s really a wonder that more of us don’t crack.

In our late 20’s and early 30’s, these stressors are much easier to swallow. Big-tour horses still fill our dreams.  But as trainers near middle age, and you look at your meager 401k, and see USDF and USEF gearing so much funding and programs to the “young professional,” dreams of CDI gallops no longer have enough shine to pull you through the hard times.  

As trainers approach midlife, our priorities are often forced to shift.  The sacrifices we made in our 20’s and 30’s to make ends meet no longer seem worth it.  Because at the end of the day, no one asks how much we sacrificed or how hard we worked, only if we achieved our goal.

I have watched so many of my peers change their goals, and find other lines of work to have a more stable income source. They shift to part-time, or leave the industry all together.  All to achieve some form of stability, and hopefully a work-life balance. But when we’ve been our own boss most of our working career, in a field that most of the world doesn’t even know about, this transition time is really, really hard. 

I am saying all of this because knowledge builds empathy, and empathy builds connection.  And connection is a big key to handling stress.

Right now, with Teresa’s passing on our minds, my peers are discussing how to help each other.  But I think this discussion needs to be opened to the dressage community and friends of the dressage community.  We are all looking for concrete ways, big and small, to prevent the stresses of the job from creating stress fractures.  All ideas are welcome here, please comment below or on the Straight Forward Dressage Facebook page.




x


26 comments:

  1. Beautifully written, Ange. To say that this is a difficult career is a huge understatement, and I’m always grateful for your contributions. Here’s hoping this adds to a constructive discussion.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Me too Chris. So many of us are so dedicated to what we do, we need to figure out how to support the professionals more.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Dressage 4 Kids Weekend Educational program is Jan 24-25. The entire day Saturday has an instructors track. And because these professionals aren't direct competition - it's in Connecticut but instructors come from all around - there is an opportunity to relax and bounce ideas off each other. This year's keynote speaker is a sports psychologist. I am sure much of what you mentioned will be discussed. I have relied on this program as professional support for years and years.

    ReplyDelete
  4. So manny can relate .. Perfectly on point !

    ReplyDelete
  5. This is a valuable discussion to have and my thought is that while some of the specifics are different, the horse business is not dissimilar from many small businesses. I own a chocolate business but am also a dressage rider. As small business owners the burdens and challenges can be tremendous and and it can be very "lonely at the top" for all the reasons you state. My point in all of this is that equestrian professionals may want to think about talking with other small business owners. Many colleges and SBA programs have business incubators and CEO groups developed specifically for the purpose of getting input from other business owners who are not in competing businesses but share similar challenges. Getting outside your specific industry could open up fresh ideas and insights. thank you for making the effort to start the conversation.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Excellent thoughts. I agree heartily all small businesses are tough. Your suggestion to network with other business owners is wise advice. Improvements come from adopting strategies used by others in business. Most small business owners suffer from: Not enough time, not enough time and not enough of the right people working for them.

      Delete
  6. This is a wonderfully written article!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Every other sport has an "end", a time when it is over, a natural, expected time to move on to the next stage of life... Except horses.

    ReplyDelete
  8. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete

  9. Thank you for this. Boundaries and set hours are a must. Time for self care is vital. That may look different for different people. Thank you for raising awareness. I’m an owner/rider and have great empathy for the animals and all involved in our sport.

    ReplyDelete

    ReplyDelete
  10. Sadly, what you are describing is a microcosm of most working people’s lives. I supported my life with horses as a journalist. I have known many horsemen as well as journalists who had the luxury of following their passion only to find they were just one lost owner or major injury (in the case of horsemen) or one more round of layoffs or one pissed off boss (in journalism) from losing their car, home or even marriage. The stresses of modern life are real and palpable for most of us. Knowing you are not unique in your stress helps, but working people also deserve the kind of job security previous generations have known. Of course that is much more difficult for horse trainers, who are at the mercy of a shrinking customer base and often fickle owners. But keep in mind, when the middle class had more expendable income and less stress, the equestrian world was booming and there were a lot more horse shows, stables, trainers and a larger customer base with many more affordable, entry-level opportunities for prospective riders to become involved.

    ReplyDelete
  11. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I really appreciate you bringing your perspective to the b discussion and that's why the line about corporate life is in there. But I could only talk about the perspective from the horse industry because that is my perspective. This is my attempt to help people get over the "grass is always greener" mentality. I'm offering them an opportunity to walk a mile in my shoes. That is all.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Being an entrepreneur in any field is a choice,....one that involves all the factors in that particular field, one that needs constant evolving to keep up in that field, constant change to keep profitable. If you're going in the red, running out of energy, resources, or it's just not working, changes need to be made sooner than later... in ANY field. Constant assessment of what parts of your biz are profitable, what parts suck energy/resources, with care not to put too much in one client in case of loss of that client, need to be made on going. A talented passionate rider & competitor does not make for a successful business.... filling a need for your client does. Any business is that way. Find a need, fill it at a profit & you will have a successful business. This is completely separate from your riding skills and passion for what you do.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anonymous, what you are not accounting for is that the skills and passion refill the fire that we can then give to our clients. This is separate from the financial gains. But whereas some jobs you make enough money you're willing to do the work, in this business, Passion is crucial because it's not a high profit industry.

      Delete
  14. yes I agree that your skills and passion will help you succeed and have longevity! But a business plan that works is the foundation. Whatever pays your bills deserves your consecration of thought to ensure it's upward progression. THAT will also fuel your passion as your life is then working & you are taking care of you along the way. I do adore horse people by the way! and have sent several to trainers, with most lacking biz savvy... that would keep them in the game long term & fund their future as well

    ReplyDelete
  15. This was very sad to read . Reading that burnout is happening in many barns and small businesses. This is easier said than done, there are people through no fault of their own can just suck the energy right out of you . Then there are people who can just fill you with energy. Someone said you must take care of yourself first . This is so true . When we do this we become the people who fill others. Some also talked of passion . You must find this for life. As these great horses carry us enjoy ! Then as teachers your passion becomes contagious! Talking and learning from peers you will find have much of the same concerns . Anyone can broaden their scope through constructive conversation. We are not perfect so enjoy the journey of being your best. That is good enough !

    ReplyDelete
  16. This was very sad to read . Reading that burnout is happening in many barns and small businesses. This is easier said than done, there are people through no fault of their own can just suck the energy right out of you . Then there are people who can just fill you with energy. Someone said you must take care of yourself first . This is so true . When we do this we become the people who fill others. Some also talked of passion . You must find this for life. As these great horses carry us enjoy ! Then as teachers your passion becomes contagious! Talking and learning from peers you will find have much of the same concerns . Anyone can broaden their scope through constructive conversation. We are not perfect so enjoy the journey of being your best. That is good enough !

    ReplyDelete
  17. Karen Rohlf of DressageNaturally.net is having a seminar specifically to help horse industry people find ways to get their lives back and actually be more successful too. She has some great success stories from past attendees if you can make it to Ocala, FL Feb 12-13th. Just thought I'd put it out there if some of you may want to look it up and get some much needed support.

    ReplyDelete
  18. And, at the end of my day I ask “IF” anyone really cares... or Life past middle age and as the day ends one becomes the invisible person.

    ReplyDelete
  19. This is a well written article, thank you for sharing it. I think the struggle is to find the balance (if there is any) between being fit to compete at high levels to bring in business and being healthy mentally, physically, and financially to have a fulfilling life. This is extraordinarily hard even when you are not literally being judged! We just need to start talking about it, support each other, and not let the judges outside the arena drive the decisions we make in life. Just my 2 cents and something that is very important to me.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Interesting article. I recently read a similar one from a H/J trainer's perspective. I come with a different perspective, as I am not a trainer, but an amateur owner. I have, however, experienced frustrations related to some of the issues you describe. I have lost many really good trainers as they have had to "re-locate" to better "opportunities". I followed one trainer to 4 different barns. I have even lost some good ones who just threw in the towel for a different career. In many of these cases, I did not have a plan B. I don't live in an area booming with decent trainers. Since its an unregulated industry, anybody who wants to become a trainer can put up a website. I have lost so much money, time and confidence sifting through. My horses have suffered unnecessary injuries and confidence problems as well. Long story short, not sure of the solution, but you are not alone and its not a "one-sided" struggle.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Add to this feeling like you are maybe sorting everything out but then you get to a show with outstanding prep for your FEI horse and students and it all goes south.. Not only have your expectations for hard work and sacrifice gone unrewarded, everyone sees you ride and looks online for your scores. Then maybe your student or students have frustrating rides for any number of reasons. And you feel hopeless. This is the difference between a normal small business owner and a dressage professional. It’s everything any other sport trainer/competitor contends with and any other small business owner navigates plus the compounded factor of another athlete (the horse) and public, readily available, critique. I think , unfortunately, the answer is awareness of the big black holes and a plan to cope with them when one inevitably falls in one. The information and support can come from a multitude diverse sources. Some mentioned in this thread.and hopefully inspired by this well introduced discussion. As I’ve gotten older I’m finding I can avoid the big holes more often.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Well stated .... why U.S. cannot support trainers like Europe does is beyond me. They whip Americans butts too often to count in Olympic so might be their edge to work at their compassion freely supported financially. Hell anyone would work happier that way......

    ReplyDelete